March 31, 2004

Time to Move to Canada

Filed under: open — Wendy @ 12:10 pm

An Ottawa Federal Court has denied the Canandian Recording Industry’s (CRIA’s) demand for the names of alleged music sharers, on grounds that remind us why diversity in copyright laws is a good thing: Canada’s got this one right.

The court ruled that plaintiffs had not shown that they had the right targets or that their targets infringed copyright (they failed to “establish a prima facie case against the unknown alleged wrongdoer”).

  • Downloading a song for personal use does not amount to infringement

  • Placing personal copies into a shared directory is not “distributing” or “authorizing the reproduction” of sound recordings
  • There was no evidence of knowledge, necessary to secondary infringement liability

Congrats to the Canadian Internet Policy and Public Interest Clinic, whose intervention helped the court get there.

The court “cannot see a real difference between a library that places a photocopy machine in a room full of copyrighted material and a computer user that places a personal copy on a shared directory linked to a P2P service.” The court also held that the CRIA had delayed its requests too long, presented too little evidence of methods for tracking users, and would have to reimburse ISPs if it were ever permitted discovery.

4 Comments

  1. Court quashes music industry bid for IDs

    Canada’s Federal Court has ruled against a motion which would have allowed the music industry to begin suing individuals who make music available on-line. Justice Konrad von Finckenstein ruled Wednesday that the Canadian Recording Industry Association …

    Trackback by Preoccupations — March 31, 2004 @ 12:47 pm

  2. An Unenthusiastic Response to the Canadian Filesharing Decision

    Co-Copyfighter and EFF attorney Wendy Seltzer has triumphantly written up the recent decision in the Canadian Recording Industry Association’s (CIRA’s) demand for filesharers names (Time to Move to Canada). Read the decision: BMG v. Jane Doe [PDF]. Fur…

    Trackback by The Importance of... — March 31, 2004 @ 3:38 pm

  3. More on the Canadian Recording Industry Association’s big loss

    The Canadian Recording Industry Association plans to appeal a Federal Court of Canada ruling yesterday that not only denied CRIA’s request to f…

    Trackback by David Akin — April 1, 2004 @ 7:15 am

  4. File-sharing ruling opens Pandora’s box

    Here’s my story from today’s Globe and Mail: While at the University of Waterloo, Matt Goyer and his housemates didn’t want to buy premium televisi…

    Trackback by David Akin — April 2, 2004 @ 3:42 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Powered by WordPress